Inspired by Peter Griffin its the ... Weekly Grind My Gears:

You know what really grinds my gears?

This section of our blog. It has become somewhat tedious writing and reading this section.
Want Some Old Rusty Gears?

Monday, July 13, 2009

A Reflection on Today's Society:

Has the creation of internet communication rendered an entire generation illiterate?

To some, this post may seem random and unprovoked; however, after a discussion regarding the above issue over dinner at Taco Mac recently, I have decided to examine the topic a little more in depth. I was originally going to use this as the weeks "Grind my Gears," but after thinking about it, I realized the length was going to be too great and it should be an entire blog post instead. Hell, if some dude could write an entire book on the subject (a little different angle, but same topic and overall message), the least I could do was complete a blog entry. Below are a few questions that have troubled me over the past few years that I would like to attempt to answer. Hopefully, this post will generate discussion because I would definitely like to hear differing opinions on the subject.

Do people really misspell, use poor grammar, and demonstrate a complete lack of intellect because they are lazy or because they don't know any better?
This is a difficult question because I truly believe the answer depends on the individual. I believe some people are not intelligent, while others, for one reason or another, just don't give a shit. I'm sure sometimes it's even a combination of both possibilities. I was fortunate enough to be raised in a relatively affluent area (granted, it wasn't Bethesda, but still...)throughout my childhood and my parents were able to send me to one of the better high schools in New Hampshire. Because of this, and my subsequent college education at a top university, I continually convince myself that my acquaintances are not actually stupid, they are just lazy. After extensive reflection, I've come to realize that this may not actually be the case.

Why are the so called "educated" people butchering the English language every time they sit down to write something?
Is there some sort of sense of "rebellion" because emailing/ instant messaging/ blog posting/ etc. are not being graded by teachers? Is it because individuals have become so reliant of Microsoft Word corrections that when they aren't using it, their inability to use proper spelling and grammar become evident? What happens when they do use Word? Do they believe that since the spelling and grammar check catches some errors that it actually corrects everything? Or am I giving college graduates too much credit and they really are horrible with the English language? Do people really not know the difference between there, their, and they're? Do they really not know the characteristics of different tenses? What is 1st person? 3rd person? Maybe they really don't know. Don't get me wrong here, I make mistakes sometimes as well; I'm definitely not a master at the English language by any means, but come on people! When did we learn some of these simple rules? 3rd grade?

Are these bad habits creeping into the "real world?"
Yes, absolutely. One hundred percent yes. I have many examples I could use to prove my point. Most of them occurred in college and not in my specific work setting, but those people I did group projects with have graduated and are now working somewhere aren't they?

What is the solution?
I truly do not know the answer to this one either. I'm sure as I type this post there are people much smarter and more educated than I will ever be, working on this issue, trying to find a solution. What I do know is that, when my only true interaction with someone is through one of these mediums and they continually demonstrate a lack of desire/care regarding how they are perceived, as well as an apparent inability to grasp simple concepts of the English language, I am forced to wonder if they carry their lack of attention to detail to other aspects of their life. How do they conduct themselves in the real world when these things matter? Would I be willing to collaborate on a project or conduct business with any of them? While I have been unable to answer many of the questions I addressed here, I can answer the last one without hesitation: emphatically NO.



5 comments:

  1. Well I guess I'll attempt to get some discussion rolling. Growing up in the south, I know I don't speak perfect english and sometimes skip an infinitive. However, I have always hated "text messaging language" or "IM speak." It's something to do with the laziness of not typing 2 more letters to spell out "you" and "are" among other phonetic abbreviations.

    I think it comes from the same place ADD was born. One of my friends from SC tends to write "there" for whatever meaning of the pronunciation and even if I mention it to him, he just retorts, "(name) knows what I mean." After doing this for some years he has improved but it really seems to me that the issue stems from people not concentrating or paying attention in grade school and teachers not pressing the issue.

    I've actually noticed in some emails from my boss that he misspells words and write incomplete sentences, but he is of an older generation and types with two fingers. He does fix some errors (during a meeting he had to send a couple emails) depending who it addressed.

    and before you do it... omgzurgr8 *bang.. spray... splat.. drip drip drip*

    ReplyDelete
  2. I wouldn't entirely blame technology for the perceived degeneration of the spoken and written word in the United States. In fact I would not even go so far as to label it a degeneration. A degeneration would imply that a language is, in whatever method, losing its effectiveness as a medium of communication, in terms of accuracy, specificity, and efficiency. I would say that the English language is simply undergoing a series of healthy and normal mutations. Certain groups of English speakers are fragmenting off of the mainstream to experiment with different uses of established lexicon and syntax, as well as pioneering their own. They do so not only to tailor standard English to their own unique situation, but to vary the levels of the three aforementioned qualities of a language to better suit their communication needs. Technological advances such as mobile phones and the internet are not the harbinger of change in language, but merely an accelerant for a transition that has been omnipresent throughout history. A native speaker born in 1923 might frown on a modern adolescent expression of courtship "luv u 4er" (sent via mobile text) as lacking the grace and substance of a quote from Shakespeare, but that individual is not recognizing the communicative value of being able to reassure one's true love of his or her commitment of fidelity at 20 minute intervals until a reunion is possible after 5th period geometry. An older speaker might lament the fact that the vocabulary of young people often lacks 'uproarious' to describe situations of greater comic value than 'hilarious', but they fail to notice that the subtle difference between the two words is equally present in the adjectives 'lol' versus 'rofl'. These older generations are also discounting too heavily the historical 'degradations' of English, such as replacing 'thee' and 'thou' with the formality neutral 'you', or referring to a film as a 'movie' rather than a 'moving picture'. Thus while the use of English during the post-industrial era may appear to some as teetering on the precipice of advanced decay, to others it is on the cusp renaissance.

    ReplyDelete
  3. jk u guys! as a ppl, n4tion, & cultr we r all fuckt! lol… ttyl!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I would say that JRoll and Rambo are both right.

    JRoll: Sadly, a lot of people are just uneducated and quite frankly stupid. For example, most people cannot handle homonyms. There, their, and they're all sound the same and most people can't tell the difference between places, possession, and a contraction. Learn how to use it correct. It's not an instantaneous laziness, but rather not taking the time to learn how to use them right. As I've been learning in life, there are too many ignorant people out there. There always has been and always will be.

    Rmabo: The evolution of a language is a great thing. Sometimes the language evolves culturally. Up north, it's acceptable to say "yous" and down south it's acceptable to say "ya'll." Although neither are correct, the listener understands the message you are conveying. I certainly wouldn't want to use either word on a job interview. Other times, technology has helped our language evolve. Text message and instant message abbreviations and slang are fine if both parties understand each other. However, we will need educated youth that will someday write our future books and academic research articles. Thanks to the capital market, the smart will succeed.

    The interesting thing with language (in a non-academic setting) is that the tone and words you choose can help your target audience feel more comfortable. While living in the south, I'll sometimes use the southern dialect. When talking to the custodial staff, I might ask, "How you be?" Although, it is not correct, it's easier to relate and creates a friendly atmosphere.

    To further understand my point about tone and the text message language. I may slave over a simple two-sentence email to a friend for an hour, but purposely not use capitalization. I know how to use capital letters, but in that situation, I want the reader to think that it was casual and breezy.

    Whenever you use language, you are conveying a message. With proper sentence structure and grammar, you make it easier for the reader to understand you and look educated. Other times, you might be trying to seem from a certain region of the country or maybe even trying to sound younger. An old guy like me has to do that sometimes, lol.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Although it may appear that our generation (Is Drama included in that?) has become illiterate through the use of technology, I believe that the cause of this concern is more based on what programs you are viewing this deterioration of intellect.

    This may be a stretch depending on the cultural area you look at, but I believe that most high school graduates can find the problems with their spelling and grammar. They are just too lazy to do so in typing quick e-mails/IMs and short updates, such as on Twitter or AIM. These forms of communication are supposed to be informal and in some cases are brief and fleeting (maybe not really supposed to be read by anyone in Twitter's case) and can be changed quickly upon a person's return to that program. This may create the image of ignorance amongst the older populace that are just beginning to experience firsthand what these communication programs are all about. As an example my Mom uses AIM and it takes her about 4-5 minutes to write a response to me because she writes in full paragraphs instead of answering a quick question with a phrase. This delays communication between us and makes me irritated because I am used to typing in quick phrases and getting quick responses when on that program.

    Now I understand your dismay if you receive e-mails at work or have an important document such as a resume that has these errors included in it. Being lazy with your work should not happen. That, to me, shows ignorance, and if not that, lack of initiative for a person in the working world. But, if it is AIM or yahoo mail from a friend then I say let it go.

    ReplyDelete